Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Yanks, Tigers, D-Backs Mega-Deal

Yankees Get: CF Curtis Granderson (29)
Yankees Give: CF Austin Jackson (23), LHP Phil Coke (28), and RHP Ian Kennedy (25)
Tigers Get:RHP Max Scherzer (26), CF Austin Jackson (23), LHP Daniel Schlereth (24), and LHP Phil Coke (28)
Tigers Give: CF Curtis Granderson (29), and RHP Edwin Jackson (26)
Diamondbacks Get: RHP Edwin Jackson (26), and RHP Ian Kennedy (25)
Diamondbacks Give: RHP Max Scherzer (26), and LHP Daniel Schlereth (24)

What a steal for the Yankees. They get Granderson for basically an assortment of role players. The Tigers made out OK and I think it is probably the best they could hope for. The Diamondbacks just flat out messed up. Scherzer is better than Edwin Jackson and Schlereth is better than Kennedy. It just doesn't make any sense for them and reportedly they were the ones pushing for this to happen. They must really think a lot of Edwin Jackson. After all Kennedy is basically a failed prospect. The following is a profile for each of the players in the deal.

Curtis Granderson (CF)
  • 29 years old and in the prime of his career.
  • Top flight defensive center fielder. 3rd best in the league according to John Dewan's plus/minus system from Bill James Online. Average arm for a CF. Particularly good at going back on balls. 13 runs saved in 2009.
  • Rare Power/Speed combination - 35 homer power with the short porch at the new Yankee Stadium and 25 SB speed.
  • 2009 was a down year for him in OBP. Needs to bounce back there. I expect him to because he walks enough - 10% of the time.
  • Needs to cut down on strike outs to make the jump to elite levels - K's 20% of the time.
  • Will fit in nicely in the Yankees lineup batting 5th behind A-Rod.
  • Comparable to a more powerful Johnny Damon at the plate
Max Scherzer (RHP)
  • 26 years old.
  • Strike out potential is great - 9.5 K/9 innings.
  • The key for him to reach his ceiling is improving his control - 3.3 BB/9 innings.
  • Top flight fastball which he throws 70% of the time. Throws an improved change-up 17% of the time and a slider 12%.
  • Gets first batter of inning out a lot (71.4% of the time). 2.23 Runs/9 innings when he does so.
  • Should be a #1 or 2 starter down the road. At worst he could be a front line closer. Only risk with him is that he might get injured, but that's the case with all young pitchers.
Austin Jackson (CF)
  • 23 years old.
  • Not a lot of HR power (Only 4 in 2009). He is more of a gap to gap hitter. This really limits his potential
  • Average major league center fielder, above average arm
  • Speed is his top tool. Should steal 30 bases annually.
  • Strikes out way too much, but walks enough.
  • In the end he's a solid but unspectacular major league center fielder.
Edwin Jackson (RHP)
  • 26 years old.
  • Strike out stuff - 6.5 K/9 innings.
  • Walks a few too many guys - 3.5 BB/9 innings.
  • Throws 65% fastballs, 28% sliders, 5% change-ups, and 2% curveballs.
  • Gets first guy of the inning out 65% of the time.
  • #2 or 3 starter.
  • He will do great going to the NL west.
Phil Coke (LHP)
  • 28 years old
  • 95 MPH fastball. He also throws a slider and change-up.
  • Doesn't throw enough quality pitches to be a starter.
  • Can get RHers and LHers out.
  • He can hold down the 7th inning for the Tigers.
Ian Kennedy(RHP)
  • 25 years old
  • One plus pitch is his change-up which is 10-12 MPH slower than his fastball.
  • Once upon a time he was a top prospect in the Yankees organization but he turned out to be a bust.
  • Could be a fifth starter in the NL West
Daniel Schlereth (LHP)
  • D-Backs 1st round draft pick in 2008
  • Threw a lot of curveballs when he was briefly called up to the big leagues - 43%
  • He isn't a bad prospect and he is definitely better than Kennedy.
On a final note I am very impressed the Yankees did not have to give up Phil Hughes, Joba Chamberlain, or Jesus Montero to get Granderson. Great trade for the Yanks.

Stats courtesy of Bill James Online