Thursday, December 17, 2009

Halladay to the Phills, Lee to the M's Blockbuster - Phillies Perspective

This trade is so big I am going to take it in three parts. First up, the Phillies prospective.

Phillies get: Roy Halladay, Phillipe Aumont, JC Ramirez, and Tyson Gillies
Phillies give: Cliff Lee, Kyle Drabek, Travis D'Arnaud, and Michael Taylor

I don't like what the Phillies did with Cliff Lee. The Halladay part I think is good for both sides but not the Lee part. If they knew they were going to trade for Halladay why didn't they do it at the trade deadline. That would have saved them the four prospects they traded for Lee. Halladay should be absolutely dominant going from the AL East to the NL. He is my early pick for CY Young, but Lee would have also.

I also question why they traded Lee away and why they didn't get more for him. If they didn't trade Lee away for three good but not great prospects they would be the favorites to win the World Series. Imagine going up against Halladay in Lee in 4 games of the series. They would be unstoppable. Don't tell me it is about money either because Lee has a bargain contract for 2010. Plus, the Phillies have plenty of money. If they can pay Joe Blanton about $8 Million then they can pay Lee $9 Million. Another idea would have been to trade Blanton to free up some money for Lee.

The last thing is the prospects the Phillies got in return for Lee. All three of them have problems. Aumont and Ramirez are both relievers with control problems and there are questions whether Gillies will hit enough to be an everyday center fielder. He has absolutely no power. The Phillies should have been able to hold out for Brandon Morrow instead of Aumont. Quite frankly I am shocked this is the best they could get in return for Lee. The Angels were supposedly willing to give up the farm plus a major league starter for Halladay. I would be surprised if they wouldn't be willing to up more then Seattle did for Lee.

World Series runs only come around so often. The Phillies pulled the trigger on Lee to quick.