Monday, December 14, 2009

Red Sox Sign John Lackey to 5 Year Deal

The Red Sox signed Lackey to a 5 year, $85 Million deal. He is 31 years old. Throughout his career he has been a true workhorse - 5 consecutive 30+ games started and 200 innings seasons. The last two years however he has failed to make 30 starts. Do you give a guy like that a 5 year deal? I wouldn't. Lets take a look at him:
  • He will be 36 by the time this contract is done.
  • Lackey has had elbow problems the past two years. That could be in part because he throws a lot of curveballs and sliders - 40%. All of the innings Lackey has thrown may be about to catch up to him
  • His best season was 2007 when he was 29. The last 2 years he has regressed towards his career averages.
I think 5 years and 85 is too many years, too much money, and too risky. Someone was bound to overpay him, but I didn't think it would be the Red Sox. There are many fall outs from this deal. First of all it means the Red Sox are out of the Roy Halladay sweepstakes. Looking at the contract from that angle it makes sense for the Red Sox. Instead of giving up the future and a monster contract they sign a lesser pitcher but still a good one.

Secondly, the Angels are crushed by this. Anytime you lose your ace it is a big blow but the Angels don't have a suitable replacement and there is no one left on the free agent market. The only option they have is to make a trade for one. They do have a few good trade chips in Brandon Wood and Joe Saunders. I think the Angels will be haunted by the lack of a #1 starter all next year and will miss the playoffs with the Mariners stepping in to take the West.

Thirdly, I wonder what this does to the Red Sox search for a left fielder. This definitely takes money out of their budget. With Bay turning down all of their offers and demanding a 5 year deal I expect them to go after Matt Holliday. My question is where they got the money for all this. They didn't have any big contracts coming off the books like the Yankees did last year when they made their splurge.

This strengthens the Red Sox pitching but that wasn't their weakness. Their weakness is their offense. I don't think it is good team building to strengthen your strength but ignore your weakness.