Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Halladay to the Phills, Lee to the M's Blockbuster - Blue Jays Perspective

Blue Jays get: Kyle Drabek, Brett Wallace, and Travis D'Arnaud
Blue Jays give: Roy Halladay

I think the Jays new GM did as good a job with this trade as he could given the circumstances. The prospects they got back should all become every day players. One trait all the players the Jays got share is that they all are very strong mentally.

Kyle Drabek should one day replace Halladay at the top of the Jays rotation. The key with him is he needs to do better against left handed batters. He throws a power fastball and curveball that would enable him to be an elite closer if he struggles starting.

Brett Wallace is a great pure hitter who should eventually anchor the Jays lineup along with Adam Lind and Travis Snider. His problem is that he will have to shift across the diamond and play first base. That means Lyle Overbay could be expendable. Potential suiters for him include the Mariners. Travis D'Arnaud is the Jays catcher of the future. He has great raw power and should become an average defender.

I think the Jays future is very bright with young stars such as Drabek, Lind, Hill, Snider, and Wallace.

Friday, December 18, 2009

Halladay to the Phills, Lee to the M's Blockbuster - Mariners Perspective

Mariners get: Cliff Lee
Mariners give: Phillipe Aumont, Tyson Gillies, and JC Ramirez

This has the potential to be a tremendous trade for the Mariners with limited downside. To make this a good trade they have to sign Lee to an extension after the season but I think they will. Last year they paid $118 Million in salaries. I think they can fit Lee in to that type of budget.

The 1-2 of King Felix and Lee is unmatched in recent years. Their rotation combined with their great defense (Which includes 3 players - Gutierrez, Ichiro, and Wilson - who are the best at their position) should make Seattle the best pitching team in baseball next year. Their offense is suspect at best but they are at least trying to upgrade their offense with the signing of Figgins and the trade for Milton Bradley.

I am not terribly impressed with the prospect the M's gave up and that is what makes this such a great deal for them. Aumont and Ramirez both have electric stuff but appear headed for the bullpen because of control problems. Relievers can only have so much value. Tyson Gillies is one of the fasted players in the Minors or Majors. The problem with him is that he has no power and might not get on base enough to play every day. The Phillies would have done much better had they asked for Brandon Morrow and Carlos Triunfel instead of Aumont and Gillies.

My prediction for the M's next year: 93 wins and they win a battle for the West that comes down to the final week of the season.

Next up: Toronto's perspective on the deal

Thursday, December 17, 2009

Halladay to the Phills, Lee to the M's Blockbuster - Phillies Perspective

This trade is so big I am going to take it in three parts. First up, the Phillies prospective.

Phillies get: Roy Halladay, Phillipe Aumont, JC Ramirez, and Tyson Gillies
Phillies give: Cliff Lee, Kyle Drabek, Travis D'Arnaud, and Michael Taylor

I don't like what the Phillies did with Cliff Lee. The Halladay part I think is good for both sides but not the Lee part. If they knew they were going to trade for Halladay why didn't they do it at the trade deadline. That would have saved them the four prospects they traded for Lee. Halladay should be absolutely dominant going from the AL East to the NL. He is my early pick for CY Young, but Lee would have also.

I also question why they traded Lee away and why they didn't get more for him. If they didn't trade Lee away for three good but not great prospects they would be the favorites to win the World Series. Imagine going up against Halladay in Lee in 4 games of the series. They would be unstoppable. Don't tell me it is about money either because Lee has a bargain contract for 2010. Plus, the Phillies have plenty of money. If they can pay Joe Blanton about $8 Million then they can pay Lee $9 Million. Another idea would have been to trade Blanton to free up some money for Lee.

The last thing is the prospects the Phillies got in return for Lee. All three of them have problems. Aumont and Ramirez are both relievers with control problems and there are questions whether Gillies will hit enough to be an everyday center fielder. He has absolutely no power. The Phillies should have been able to hold out for Brandon Morrow instead of Aumont. Quite frankly I am shocked this is the best they could get in return for Lee. The Angels were supposedly willing to give up the farm plus a major league starter for Halladay. I would be surprised if they wouldn't be willing to up more then Seattle did for Lee.

World Series runs only come around so often. The Phillies pulled the trigger on Lee to quick.

Monday, December 14, 2009

Red Sox Sign John Lackey to 5 Year Deal

The Red Sox signed Lackey to a 5 year, $85 Million deal. He is 31 years old. Throughout his career he has been a true workhorse - 5 consecutive 30+ games started and 200 innings seasons. The last two years however he has failed to make 30 starts. Do you give a guy like that a 5 year deal? I wouldn't. Lets take a look at him:
  • He will be 36 by the time this contract is done.
  • Lackey has had elbow problems the past two years. That could be in part because he throws a lot of curveballs and sliders - 40%. All of the innings Lackey has thrown may be about to catch up to him
  • His best season was 2007 when he was 29. The last 2 years he has regressed towards his career averages.
I think 5 years and 85 is too many years, too much money, and too risky. Someone was bound to overpay him, but I didn't think it would be the Red Sox. There are many fall outs from this deal. First of all it means the Red Sox are out of the Roy Halladay sweepstakes. Looking at the contract from that angle it makes sense for the Red Sox. Instead of giving up the future and a monster contract they sign a lesser pitcher but still a good one.

Secondly, the Angels are crushed by this. Anytime you lose your ace it is a big blow but the Angels don't have a suitable replacement and there is no one left on the free agent market. The only option they have is to make a trade for one. They do have a few good trade chips in Brandon Wood and Joe Saunders. I think the Angels will be haunted by the lack of a #1 starter all next year and will miss the playoffs with the Mariners stepping in to take the West.

Thirdly, I wonder what this does to the Red Sox search for a left fielder. This definitely takes money out of their budget. With Bay turning down all of their offers and demanding a 5 year deal I expect them to go after Matt Holliday. My question is where they got the money for all this. They didn't have any big contracts coming off the books like the Yankees did last year when they made their splurge.

This strengthens the Red Sox pitching but that wasn't their weakness. Their weakness is their offense. I don't think it is good team building to strengthen your strength but ignore your weakness.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Rafael Soriano to the Rays

Rays Get: RHP Rafael Soriano (31)
Braves Get: RHP Jesse Chavez (26)

This is basically a salary dump for the Braves after Soriano caught them off guard by accepting arbitration. I still don't think the Braves were wrong to offer Soriano arbitration, after all it didn't cost them anything. If he declined arbitration they get 2 draft picks. If he accepted they trade him and still get something in return.

It seems like the Braves could have got more in return than Jesse Chavez. Chavez has some upside because he throws hard but he gives up a lot of extra base hits - opponents slugged .460 against him in 2009. He has an upside of a setup guy.

On the Rays side of things this is a great deal for them. If Soriano stays healthy, and that's a big if. He has a history of elbow problems. When he is healthy he will fill the Rays closer hole magnificently. Let's take a look at him:
  • 31 years old with elbow problems in his past.
  • Throws a fastball and slider.
  • Last year opposing batters hit .194 against him with a .267 OBP and .319 SLG%. Absolutely dominant.
  • The trip to the AL should be no problem for him - In his career he has a 2.47 ERA against teams with .500 to .599 winning percentages.
  • 40% of his innings in 2009 were 1-2-3 innings.
Last year was as good a year as he is going to have. As a 31 year with an injury filled history expect regression but he is still a huge upgrade over J.P. Howell.

Stats courtesy of Bill James Online

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Yanks, Tigers, D-Backs Mega-Deal

Yankees Get: CF Curtis Granderson (29)
Yankees Give: CF Austin Jackson (23), LHP Phil Coke (28), and RHP Ian Kennedy (25)
Tigers Get:RHP Max Scherzer (26), CF Austin Jackson (23), LHP Daniel Schlereth (24), and LHP Phil Coke (28)
Tigers Give: CF Curtis Granderson (29), and RHP Edwin Jackson (26)
Diamondbacks Get: RHP Edwin Jackson (26), and RHP Ian Kennedy (25)
Diamondbacks Give: RHP Max Scherzer (26), and LHP Daniel Schlereth (24)

What a steal for the Yankees. They get Granderson for basically an assortment of role players. The Tigers made out OK and I think it is probably the best they could hope for. The Diamondbacks just flat out messed up. Scherzer is better than Edwin Jackson and Schlereth is better than Kennedy. It just doesn't make any sense for them and reportedly they were the ones pushing for this to happen. They must really think a lot of Edwin Jackson. After all Kennedy is basically a failed prospect. The following is a profile for each of the players in the deal.

Curtis Granderson (CF)
  • 29 years old and in the prime of his career.
  • Top flight defensive center fielder. 3rd best in the league according to John Dewan's plus/minus system from Bill James Online. Average arm for a CF. Particularly good at going back on balls. 13 runs saved in 2009.
  • Rare Power/Speed combination - 35 homer power with the short porch at the new Yankee Stadium and 25 SB speed.
  • 2009 was a down year for him in OBP. Needs to bounce back there. I expect him to because he walks enough - 10% of the time.
  • Needs to cut down on strike outs to make the jump to elite levels - K's 20% of the time.
  • Will fit in nicely in the Yankees lineup batting 5th behind A-Rod.
  • Comparable to a more powerful Johnny Damon at the plate
Max Scherzer (RHP)
  • 26 years old.
  • Strike out potential is great - 9.5 K/9 innings.
  • The key for him to reach his ceiling is improving his control - 3.3 BB/9 innings.
  • Top flight fastball which he throws 70% of the time. Throws an improved change-up 17% of the time and a slider 12%.
  • Gets first batter of inning out a lot (71.4% of the time). 2.23 Runs/9 innings when he does so.
  • Should be a #1 or 2 starter down the road. At worst he could be a front line closer. Only risk with him is that he might get injured, but that's the case with all young pitchers.
Austin Jackson (CF)
  • 23 years old.
  • Not a lot of HR power (Only 4 in 2009). He is more of a gap to gap hitter. This really limits his potential
  • Average major league center fielder, above average arm
  • Speed is his top tool. Should steal 30 bases annually.
  • Strikes out way too much, but walks enough.
  • In the end he's a solid but unspectacular major league center fielder.
Edwin Jackson (RHP)
  • 26 years old.
  • Strike out stuff - 6.5 K/9 innings.
  • Walks a few too many guys - 3.5 BB/9 innings.
  • Throws 65% fastballs, 28% sliders, 5% change-ups, and 2% curveballs.
  • Gets first guy of the inning out 65% of the time.
  • #2 or 3 starter.
  • He will do great going to the NL west.
Phil Coke (LHP)
  • 28 years old
  • 95 MPH fastball. He also throws a slider and change-up.
  • Doesn't throw enough quality pitches to be a starter.
  • Can get RHers and LHers out.
  • He can hold down the 7th inning for the Tigers.
Ian Kennedy(RHP)
  • 25 years old
  • One plus pitch is his change-up which is 10-12 MPH slower than his fastball.
  • Once upon a time he was a top prospect in the Yankees organization but he turned out to be a bust.
  • Could be a fifth starter in the NL West
Daniel Schlereth (LHP)
  • D-Backs 1st round draft pick in 2008
  • Threw a lot of curveballs when he was briefly called up to the big leagues - 43%
  • He isn't a bad prospect and he is definitely better than Kennedy.
On a final note I am very impressed the Yankees did not have to give up Phil Hughes, Joba Chamberlain, or Jesus Montero to get Granderson. Great trade for the Yanks.

Stats courtesy of Bill James Online

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Roy Halladay

In this post I am going to speculate on what the leading teams to get Roy Halladay should give up for him.

Angel: LHP Joe Saunders, SS/3B Brandon Wood, and C Hank Conger
Yankees: RHP Joba Chamberlain or RHP Phil Hughes, C Jesus Montero, and RHP Ian Kennedy
Red Sox: RHP Clay Buchholz, RHP/SS Casey Kelly, RHP Manny Delcarmen, and OF Josh Reddick

I would say the best of these three offers is the Red Sox one. It's just a question of whether they would give up Kelly, which I don't think they will. Then it comes down to the Yankees and Angels. My guess is that the Yankees will decide to sign John Lackey instead of trading away the prospects. If the Yankees wouldn't give up a lot of prospects for a younger Johan Santana who's to think they would for Roy Halladay. It's not as if not doing the Santana deal backfired on them. That leaves the Angels. They will be in great need of pitching if they lose Lackey who was their ace. They might need to throw in a player but I think the Blue Jays won't get any better offers. Wood was a uber-prospect not to long ago. He just hasn't fit in with the Angels. Conger would fill the Jays hole at catcher and Saunders gives them an above average third pitcher on a championship team. In the end I think he will go to the Angels right before spring training.

Sleeper: Atlanta Braves
Long Shot: Texas Rangers
Not Going to Happen: Dodgers and Phillies