Thursday, December 3, 2009

Roy Halladay

In this post I am going to speculate on what the leading teams to get Roy Halladay should give up for him.

Angel: LHP Joe Saunders, SS/3B Brandon Wood, and C Hank Conger
Yankees: RHP Joba Chamberlain or RHP Phil Hughes, C Jesus Montero, and RHP Ian Kennedy
Red Sox: RHP Clay Buchholz, RHP/SS Casey Kelly, RHP Manny Delcarmen, and OF Josh Reddick

I would say the best of these three offers is the Red Sox one. It's just a question of whether they would give up Kelly, which I don't think they will. Then it comes down to the Yankees and Angels. My guess is that the Yankees will decide to sign John Lackey instead of trading away the prospects. If the Yankees wouldn't give up a lot of prospects for a younger Johan Santana who's to think they would for Roy Halladay. It's not as if not doing the Santana deal backfired on them. That leaves the Angels. They will be in great need of pitching if they lose Lackey who was their ace. They might need to throw in a player but I think the Blue Jays won't get any better offers. Wood was a uber-prospect not to long ago. He just hasn't fit in with the Angels. Conger would fill the Jays hole at catcher and Saunders gives them an above average third pitcher on a championship team. In the end I think he will go to the Angels right before spring training.

Sleeper: Atlanta Braves
Long Shot: Texas Rangers
Not Going to Happen: Dodgers and Phillies